Critique Ettiquette Sequel
Foz just emailed us asking the 2nd years to give a small lecture in front of our work to the first years
He claims our pearls of wisdom are so great the first years must know them.
I have no pearls of wisdom.
I,
am,
an,
idiot
But I do have some additional rules for acceptable Critique Ettiquette.
18. Drawing during a crit to while away tedious hours is tempting but must be resisted at all costs.
To do this in front of Foz would be like eating peas with a knife in front of the Queen.
19. It is possible to amuse yourself instead by giving invaluable [hah!] feedback to thy peers.
20. Chewing innumerable packs of gum helps stave away both hunger and boredom. Thou shalt be rewarded by minty fresh breath as thou hurls venom at thy classmate.
21. Caffeine is not thy friend if thou art clumsy. This rules applies to any liquid.
22. Learn Indesign & Flash for it shall save thy lowly life when thou has not found freelance illustration work and have just realized paint is inedible.
23. ‘Nice’ and ‘cool’ are still forbidden words and thou shalt be socially ostracized and flogged for such heresy.
The Private View
Had the exam board meeting at 2 o clock today (Just re-read this – What? I don’t remember any exam board! What have I written? – It is now Sunday the 24th of June) followed by the long-awaited Private View at 6 p.m.
Our ‘Big Day’ was discussed among the women purely in terms of shoes and clothes. Forget art darling, what the hell are you wearing?
At the very last-minute I had an absolutely ingenious idea to iron my skirt on the floor of my room. Being a first-rate nitwit I dropped the hot iron on the carpet and burned it slightly thus leaving the lovely residue of melted beige carpet on the iron which I then expertly placed on top of my black skirt.
Decided it would be an even better idea to then scrub carpet cleaner on my skirt with a loofah. To cut a long story short all the burning and panicked attempted mending fucked in no particular order:
- My skirt
- My carpet
- My punctuality
Then decided to send a badly worded text message to both Georgina & Onnalin apologizing for my lateness and explaining my accident with the iron. I say badly worded because then everyone, including the external examiner, was concerned that with my past arson history I had somehow burned myself badly. Disillusioning them to the lamer truth was slightly embarrassing. I almost wish I had burned myself just to save face (I’d probably have enjoyed the sympathy).
The external examiner spoke to Ed, Alex and me in a little group. He was far easier than F&G. I found I spoke much more clearly about my content than I did at the assessment (again, what a dolt). The external examiner was very nice, very calm, lots of open ended questions. He also asked about the blog (which I made into a book since a lot of the rants were related to my drawings.)
Alex opened the first page of his portfolio (not being in the Show), showed nothing else and blamed everything on
“Not finding a subject I’m interested in.”
What a load of….
Anyway aside from Martyn (a gentlemen of great sense and discernment) everyone is beginning to take the stupid trite on my blog far too seriously.
Adam came up to me the other day and said in a vaguely threatening manner
“Hey! I was reading your blog the other day………..*pause for effect*…… and I WAS NOT CUDDLING THAT GIRL!! I WAS NOT!!”
Georgina shrieked at me like a harpy
“You wrote untrue things about me! I never used the stethoscope to eavesdrop on Foz’s crit with Alex!”
Just in case people assume it’s also the truth, I’d like to confirm that harpies are indeed fictional. Nor did G. shriek, she said everything in the politest, mildest way possible.
After being so wired for nearly 3 weeks we were getting slowly but surely smashed as the evening wore on. At 9 the Mall shut and all networking or selling prints was over (I sold nothing, nada, zilch *sob sniff sniff*) we went to the ICA to continue drinking.
Not only did this piece of shit excuse for a bar charge us £1.50 entry (what the fuck? It’s a fucking shitty bar, not even a good bar. A bloody average canteen). But clearly catering to all the stuffed old fogies that regularly haunt the ICA they had banned smoking early (what fucking nerve). Being a bunch of first-rate rimmers to boot we were also banned you from drinking outside.
So, either you smoke or you drink, but never both at the same time. Nothing infuriates me more than this type of stupid-ass fucking thumbs-up-their-arse rules. I hate nagging non-smokers. They piss me right off. Go fucking live in a vegan, non-dairy, celibate, organic hippie carbon free commune you healthy self-righteous fucks.
*deep breath*
Foz looked fairly sober to me so I was slightly taken aback when he went on a mildly disturbing anti-Foz spiel about when he’s reads the stuff he says in crits he thinks: I’m such a twat, what I say is so rubbish, ought to give up teaching all together, throw in the towel, I’m such a bastard, so harsh, I’m as subtle as an ax, everything I say is wrong, I’m just going to quit, too blunt, fucking sledge-hammer and all that self-critical nonsense. (basically a load of ‘Lisa’)
I really don’t know what more this man wants.
He had girls draped over him all night, sobbing and crying melodramatically in their low-cut, eye-level tops, cleavages collectively smothering him, while every now then, amongst the sea of heaving bosoms, his little head would bob into view, before going under once again.
“Foz we love you, we’ll miss you. Will you miss us? You’d better miss us! I bet you’ll forget us. Will you? Will you miss us? Sob sob sniff sniff boo hoo”
they all wailed in unison.
Roderick stands on the edge of this little circle, ignored. He shakes his head and calls us a bunch of groupies (his jealousy is transparent).
If all of this doesn’t validate Foz’s teaching skills I really don’t know what will. I’m so definitely becoming a tutor if it’s the last thing I do.
The mood swung from fairly festive to downright maudlin. All the mauling and whirlwind emotions seem to leave Foz semi-suicidal, sitting at a table with his head in his hands. So I go out for a cigarette hoping to alleviate, at the very least, my mood.
While Fernanda is in the midst of a flood of tears on Foz’s shoulder’s, she suddenly turns, punches me in the arm and yells
“You never fucking cry! You’re a fucking stone cold bitch woman!”
I was trying very hard not to look at all this hideous display of tears.
“Look to the left, look to the right, on the floor. Think of Venice yes I’m in Venice la la la tra la la I’m on a gondola, we’re sailing along, moonlit sky….”
before Fernanda yanked me out of my emotional avoidance.
I rather resent all the crying these days, it dampens the atmosphere every time. Why can’t these women just be emotionally repressed and in denial like the rest of us stone cold bitches?
I join Amalia outside for a smoke. The bouncer refuses to let her back in because she took her drink outside. Amalia decides to battle it out against the brutish 6ft, 3 tonne, female giantess.
“How can I be deeeeenied entrrrrrry for a fucking drrink? It was my friends drink out of the bottal and eet was’nt even from in this stupid fucking bar okaaay?. Eets rrrridikulus. Eets ridikulus! Well I’m not going to move frrrom herrre so why don’t you jaaaast call the police then. No, I’m not going. You think you caaan physically rrrremove me? You can’t no you can’t because I’m not going okaaaay?”
Eoghan (or Owen) a 6 ft Irishman tries reasoning with the bouncer, who responds with
“If you don’t move out of my way, I will physically remove you and then I’m going to physically remove her, call the police and have her charged with drunk & disorderly conduct and trespassing ok?”
Eoghan scampers off tail between his legs. I coax Amalia out of getting her knee-caps broken and she goes outside still grumbling angrily
“Eets fucking ridikulus! What the fuck? I mean, what a fucking beeetch!”
Gary came back suddenly like a hero, riding in (I’m certain) to save Foz before all his female students throttle him with love. He whisked Foz away on to the back of his bold stallion (mates car) and off they went, into the dark night.
We all part ways and I walk down to the bus stop at Trafalgar square, stale wine and the taste of fags lining the roof of my mouth and I suddenly feel immensely depressed about everything.
The Assessment
Self-absorbed post (when are they not?). Mostly about my own assessment and generally written for my benefit. I therefore strongly advise you to skip.
Just returned from my assessment at the Mall with Foz and Gary feeling dazed, breathless and slightly giddy.
I get out in a fog at Brixton, walk across to the other platform and sit on the train waiting expectantly. I’m surprised to find myself home already, I can’t recall changing tubes at Stockwell at all. I wander out in an absent-minded way, playing things over and over in my head. Sainsbury’s was a distant dream of buying random food I now won’t eat.
Foz & Gary both questioned me inside out and I tried to be as honest as possible without being self-effacing. There is a fine line that I can’t seem to locate between self-deprecating, fake modesty, overly critical, overly confident and being too cocky.
I have no idea how well or badly I did. I might have been so unclear and rambling I was none of the above. I did go off on a rant about hijabs at one point (god knows why).
Gary asks me if I think I try to see both sides of the argument.
“Yes.”
I say, I can. Obviously I’m biased towards my own views, but can still understand what the other sides argument is. (I just don’t agree with it)
They just came at me again and again, first Gary’s upper cut from the left, then Foz with a half nelson from the right both working together like Mexican wrestling tag team. I felt quite battered by the end of it.
With Foz at least, its all laid out there on the table - This is what I think, I like this, I hate that. He can’t really disguise his feelings well. It all shows on his face and in his eyes. Now perhaps if he was a thief, he’d probably be the kind of guy who would forget to wear a ski mask and mug you by jumping out in front of you in the middle of the afternoon. The police would be on to him like a shot.
Gary on the other hand is a sly fellow. You can never tell exactly what he’s thinking, there is this murky gray area within his opinion. Before you know it he’s sneaked up behind you and clonked you round the back of your head. He might say something which (being a thick head like me) takes some time to digest, and then it dawns on you….
“Wait a minute…he wasn’t being complimentary…. he was saying you’re rubbish!”
He would be the kind of mugger to grab you from behind in a dark alley, take your bag, purse/wallet, phone, ipod and then frog march you to the nearest cash point and empty your bank account. Strong words I know, but they both grilled me like a bitch.
I kept standing up or kneeling and doing everything but sitting in my appointed chair. Foz kept reminding me like I was a naughty school child. Sit still stupid, and stop fidgeting.
“You always talk about the aesthetic but do you feel that you think about your content enough?”
‘Enough’ is the word that really gets me. How do you define ‘enough’?
I got the feeling that they think I don’t consider my content enough.
And yes I think about content a great deal, but for me, on my MA colour and practicalities like reducing time it takes to finish a piece to satisfaction have been much more of a struggle. It was about more than just content.
A recurring theme I’ve noticed over the last 5 years in art school is the whole hoo-hah about the importance of content.
Content and good ideas are valuable assets but nothing is so easily destroyed as a great idea badly presented. There is always this thing in art colleges, and Camberwell (my old college) in particular, where they say
“We’re not here to teach you to draw, it’s about pushing your content and your ideas”
One of the major problems I have is the notion that substance is more important than how it’s represented. I think, personally, that you can’t separate technical development and content development. They work in tandem; sometimes one gains more priority, sometimes another.
The impression I’ve consistently got from Gary (and not just today) is that content is and always must be the priority.
But my agenda has to include both. If not equally then 60% aesthetic 40% content. Disagree with this as you will philosophers, dissertation lovers and information designers. I find nothing is so dull as interesting information plotted out on a tedious graph. (come to the our show and you’ll see what I mean)
Unfortunately I never said any of this. I have a persistent and malignant case of esprit de l’escalier. It’s damn annoying.
Worst question by far was right at the end of the CIA interrogation:
“What is it that you’ve mastered?”
Foz demands to know. I say ‘the worst question’ for a 2 reasons:
1. My answer could have been better (for a start)
I’m worn down by now so I just said ‘Colour.’ Colour is the thing that’s dramatically changed for me the most.
The thing I had to really get my head around and thing I struggled with and still struggle with the most. But it’s certainly not the only thing.
Sadly, none of this is discussed. Since they seem to be hurrying me out, I just mention colour.
“Is that enough?”
they ask frighteningly.
“No..”
I mutter, rattling off something else that I can’t recall.
There was something about being self-critical, writing the blog making me more coherent, sharper, remembering things better, which is clearly all rubbish because right now for the life of me I can’t remember half the things I was spouting.
2. The second reason why it was the worst question was because of the question itself.
‘What are you trying to master?’ and ‘What have you mastered?’ are two completely different questions that dictate two completely different answers.
‘What are you trying to master?’ is a good question. It suggests you’re trying to work something out, constantly moving towards a goal.
‘What have you mastered?’ suggests finality. It’s a bit poncy and meaningless. What does the word ‘master’ mean anyway?
To me it means you’ve done all that can be done, know all that you can know about a subject or technique and are at the top of your game. It implies others will come to you, humbly begging to be graciously allowed to apprentice under your phenomenal tutelage. (if only)
I’m bloody 25 I can’t possible have mastered anything and even at 45 can you say in all honesty (unless you’re an arrogant prick) that you have completely mastered any one thing? It’s always in flux (I’m fairly sure F&G will heartily disagree…or maybe not fuck knows. My brain is fried.)
Now an exception would be Yoda, he certainly was a Jedi master, but
a. He is 900 years old
b. He’s fucking fictional
(Foz disagrees, He’s not fictional, no he’s not, Yoda is real, he asserts. I get the feeling that I must at all cost, not shatter this fragile belief.)
Unfortunately I didn’t say any of this either. God I’m such a dolt.
Things to do before the show
Monday
- Before have a list to people to invite! (Do it now you lazy fuck!)
- Printout form for A5 postcards (done)
- Return library books (done)
- Pick up silkscreen prints (done)
Tuesday
- Cooker Hood to need fixing, call nick handyman and get quote. (do it bitch!)
- Buy A4 portfolio (black or pink or green? I love the green but maybe that’s too distracting, maybe just black?)
for sketch work to display at the show, (done, bought brown) - Buy Inkjet Cartridge R240 from (Cass Art Angel)
- Buy another frame Habitat (Regent Street)
- Layout Book to sell, calculate pages + cover and Back
- Prepare Tiff for A2 print of Tea Party to sell
Wednesday
- Buy 2 packs bockinford/watercolour paper (but not too thick), ink jet paper from John Purcell (Stockwell)
(done bought from cass art 9) - Cut A3 pack of paper from JP (College)
- Frame work for crit (College)
- Buy 6 mirror plates (Tool shop, College)
- Cull Mailout list, do research 20-30 people? (do it on Tuesday do it now!!!)
- SEND MAIL OUT INVITES TO JOYCE!!!
Thursday
- Crit all day
Saturday
- Print out 3 books for the show on , 1 for display 2 to sell
- Covers? Same as website I think. Clean
- Borrow R’s drill set and screwdriver: Use for mirror frames and also to bind your books? or get Michelle to stitch it? or call City for a quote for 5 books. Maybe just loose leaf set in a plastic pack?
Monday
- Get Ro to print 1 book,
- Call City Book Binders to Bind 2 books?
Hanging Crit Sequel

Yesterday we had a little meeting on how much space we get in the show determined by last weeks hanging crit.
On one hand Foz said he dreaded this time of year because people tend to get paranoid and start reading into things too much (for example if someone gets more space in the show and someone else gets less.)
Unfortunately when he was later backed into an uncomfortable corner by an angry and overly emotional student he said quite frankly
“Well you’ve only got 2 meters instead of 3 because I don’t think you have enough work to put in the show”
So…..what shall I say? I feel paranoid already
Onnalin and Georgina accuse me of taking pleasure in other peoples misery.
I find this unfair in the extreme (partially true but still unfair). I do not consider getting stroppy about having 2 meters of space in the show as opposed to 3, reasonable grounds for ‘misery’.
Cancer is misery or perhaps losing someone you love (like a dog) but amateur dramatic were designed to be mocked. Of course this includes me missing my flight and burning down the kitchen. I was highly melodramatic at the time but in retrospect it was hugely funny, therefore logically I do not see why others should be spared.
I reminded Gerogina and Onnalin that many crits ago we (especially us 3+ Foz) all sort of made someone cry. Georgina looked absolutely aghast with horror,
“We made her cry?? No no! What are you saying??!! No I didn’t oh my god!!”
Now that was funny.
Hanging Crit
This does not imply any of the illustrators are growing suicidal.
No.
(For some it might be true, but still. No.)
It’s about hanging up your work in the gallery space, your plans for it, your space requirements, frames etc.
Foz had previously threatened the class that if we didn’t give him the right dimensions/or layout plans he just wouldn’t bother to crit the space/the body of work on display. If nothing else that goaded me into staying late last night and bashing my head in.
So it was particularly infuriating when a bunch of people seemed to have not bothered or were just being all fucking wishy-washy and still got a crit (Foz is a very forgiving master)……a very very lengthy crit. A crit of nearly ceaseless yawning, that lasted well past 8:30, during which for the last hour and a half I couldn’t stop gritting my teeth.
Although not going through with a threat does seems to devalue any future threats I suppose being forgiving is a good thing. Well actually, it is a good thing but thats not what bothers me. (As always, I shall happily discuss what bothers me later.)
At some point I had visions of hurling myself at particularly time-consuming students and throttling them. Fucks sake man. 6 and a half hours in a crit! You spend less time waiting for a Visa! For fucks sake.
* Beware!! Rant to follow *
I have some serious problems with this egg-timer business. The first 3 people and the last 3 people to go get a raw deal. They get 10 minutes flat and that’s it and the last 3 people don’t even get the same level of energy and attention because by then everyone is exhausted.
By the middle Foz or Gary’s strictness with the timer slips leaving the door wide open for some people who then fucking talk and talk and fucking talk some more but add absolutely nothing to the conversation.
I have no objection to extensive feedback but mostly time is just wasted by some people waffling on and on and saying nothing.
Why does anyone need 20 minutes to talk anyway? You’re not saying anything that can’t be condensed into 2 minutes. At least let people give you feedback properly and stop being so fucking vague. I don’t see why other people have to suffer for a wafflers inability to be concise or clear.
Perhaps you might think I’m being a bit mean or unfair? But this is the final term, on the second year of a communication course. There is no justifiable ground to be charitable at all for poor communication. It’s equally unfair to the people who go first or last.
* End of rant *
By the end of the hanging crit I did want to hang some people. The thought of the pub was the only thing that kept me driven. God bless alcohol.
Martyn, Georgina and Ed (who were the last 3) get no real attention from anyone except Foz and Gary who have an amazing unwavering focus. My teeth on the other hand, have been ground down to stubs.
Highlights of the day:
Alex:
Sigh. Alex makes me cringe. I know he’s going to get a bollocking every time, and every time he doesn’t nothing to prevent it. His entire attitude is one of a surly teenager.
I bet he’ll go on to write a book about how he went to St. Martins and everyone in his class was stuck up and he was like, ‘the outsider maaan’ and like, nobody ‘got him’ man. Whats there to fucking get? He just doesn’t seem to give a shit. He hasn’t for a while.
Gary was severe in his disapproval
“…. and personally I would like you to be in the show but your attitude seems to suggest you don’t really care, and if you don’t care then I’d say you’re just not going in the show…..because its everybody’s show… and if the work isn’t good enough it’s not fair to everybody else……I don’t know that’s just me …what does everybody else think?”
We all nod and murmur.
(For Gary that was pretty damn harsh)
Chris:
Foz goes on to ask,
“I think this large drawing looks a lot like a photocopy Chris…”
Chris replies
“but it is a photocopy Foz”
You know those cartons where the guy whips out a big frying pan and whacks himself on the head? That was Foz.
Tiphane:
Kept saying ‘shiiith’ instead of ‘sheet’ in her beautiful French accent and 1/8 of the class giggled quietly like nitwits (including me)
Tiphane is happily oblivious to such juvenile behavior.
PS – The studio has grown more and more like a tip and I can no longer give any credit to Ed alone for this.
I’d like to say I remembered more but all the yawning distracted me entirely.
Tuesday core time
Geoff really worries me. I feel like he’s constantly on the verge of a nervous breakdown.
Becky politely asked him how he was and he said
“Oh oh uhm not so good uhm my head’s in a bit of a muddle this time of year, yes so I have to say Geoff no…mumble mumble… “
and then shuffled off nervously.
I have no idea what he says half the time, his sentences occasionally trail off into that PG Wodehouse, very english-english gibberish if you know what I mean.
We were passed around the itinerary for the ICA show as well as the layout plans for our allotted spaces.
He seemed extremely anxious and twitchy as he read out the very extensive and comprehensive list of things to do, occasionally turning back towards Andy and the other tutors as if for encouragement. He continued to twitch and rock back and forth in a slightly autistic way. It was mildly disturbing since last years course leader was a real ball breaker kind of woman.
Then Andy stepped up to take over. Much more the man in control. He stands straight and gives orders with a certain authority that overshadows Geoff entirely.
On the other hand Geoff managed to get the dean to fund our show so we no longer have to shell out a 100 quid of our student bank pittance. (Which is an incredible feat really the entire bill for the ICA venue is £10,000)
After Core time Andy came to the Illustration studio to be faced with my drawing of a woman very graphically giving birth. I got the feeling he wanted to turn it over.
Fernanda began to rattle off a list of demands
“Well, what I neeed for the show is a space where I can hang theese big acrylic prints I maaade and I waant them to be one in front of each other like that and you can see and theeen I want them hanging from the ceiling like that but with some space in front of them like thaat…”
“….yesss ok well theeeen I want another thing to hang my photographs….”
Andy rubs his forehead
“and theeeen I want to built this acrylic coffin light box and the floor so you walk around it and look down into it and you can see the things and then…..”
Andy rubs his forehead some more.
Onnalin doesn’t get to see Andy immediately and throws a small tantrum, yelling and stamping her feet at Martyn, then flopping onto a chair and pouting.
Martyn being entirely an unsympathetic man mocks her by imitating her foot stamping and sulking.
Being entirely unsympathetic ourselves, we all laugh

























































Fools